Humic acid, humate and fulvic acid supplier · Own factory in Shanxi, China

Email: info@humicacid.org

Home / Blog

Soil Organic Matter vs Humic Products: What an Application Can and Cannot Change

Soil organic matter and humic products are often discussed as if they were the same thing. They are related, but they differ greatly in scale. This article works through the arithmetic for a typical topsoil, describes what builds soil organic matter, and sets out what a humic acid application can and cannot change in that respect.

What soil organic matter is

Soil organic matter (SOM) is the organic fraction of soil: plant and animal residues at different stages of decomposition, microbial cells and their products, and material that has been processed further and persists longer (Weil and Brady 2017).

Laboratories usually measure soil organic carbon and may convert it to organic matter with a factor. The conventional factor is 1.724, which assumes that organic matter is 58% carbon. That factor has itself been critically reviewed (Pribyl 2010). Check whether your report gives organic carbon or organic matter, and which factor it uses.

How SOM is pictured is also debated. Lehmann and Kleber (2015) argued that it is better understood as a continuum of progressively decomposing organic compounds than as large, distinct humic molecules formed in soil. Olk et al. (2019) replied that humic fractions extracted with alkali remain relevant in environmental and agricultural research. Either way, the humic acid in a bag of leonardite-derived product is a mined and processed material. It is not the same thing as a soil’s own organic matter.

Worked example: how much organic matter a topsoil holds

The assumptions below are illustrative. They are not measurements of any particular field; replace them with your own soil test values.

  • Area: one hectare (10,000 m²).
  • Depth: 0.20 m, a typical plough layer.
  • Bulk density: 1.3 t per m³ (1.3 g per cm³).
  • Soil organic matter: 2.0% by mass.

The arithmetic:

  1. Soil volume: 10,000 m² × 0.20 m = 2,000 m³.
  2. Soil mass: 2,000 m³ × 1.3 t per m³ = 2,600 t.
  3. Organic matter: 2,600 t × 0.020 = 52 t.
  4. Organic carbon, using the conventional factor: 52 t ÷ 1.724 ≈ 30 t.

So under these assumptions the plough layer of one hectare holds about 52 t of organic matter, or about 30 t of organic carbon. A deeper layer, a denser soil or a higher SOM content gives a larger stock.

Per tonne applied

Now a hypothetical number, used only for the arithmetic and not as a recommendation or an application rate: suppose one tonne of organic matter is added to that hectare and none of it decomposes.

  • Organic matter rises from 52 t to 53 t, in 2,601 t of soil.
  • SOM rises from 2.00% to about 2.04%, an increase of about 0.04 percentage points.
  • The added tonne is about 2% of the stock already there (1 ÷ 52 ≈ 0.019).

A tonne of product as delivered is less than a tonne of organic matter. Take our humic acid granule HA-01G. Its TDS states organic matter ≥ 85.0% (dry basis) and moisture ≤ 25.0%. At the moisture limit, one tonne as delivered holds at least 0.75 t of dry matter, and at the organic matter minimum, that dry matter holds at least about 0.64 t of organic matter (0.75 × 0.85). On the example soil, one tonne of that product therefore adds between about 0.64 t and 1 t of organic matter, roughly 1.2% to 1.9% of the existing stock.

Two cautions apply. First, the arithmetic assumes that all of the added material stays in the soil. How long applied humic material persists in a field is not stated on our TDS and will depend on conditions. Second, compare a change of a few hundredths of a percentage point with the precision your laboratory reports for SOM before you expect to see it in a soil test.

What builds soil organic matter

Soil organic matter is built mainly by regular organic inputs over many years, and it is lost through decomposition and erosion. Most of the carbon in fresh residues is released as carbon dioxide by soil organisms; a fraction remains in the soil (Weil and Brady 2017). The main inputs are:

  • crop residues and roots returned to the soil;
  • manure and compost;
  • cover crops grown between cash crops;
  • rotations that include grass or other perennial crops.

Measures that reduce erosion keep the topsoil, and the organic matter in it, in the field. SOM changes slowly, so it is tracked over years with the same sampling depth, season, laboratory and method.

What a humic application can and cannot change

A humic acid or humate application adds a known quantity of humic material, set by the amount applied and its content as stated on the TDS and reported on the batch COA. Potassium humate also supplies potassium (as K₂O; see each product’s TDS).

In terms of the soil’s organic matter stock, the arithmetic above shows the limit. Unless very large quantities are applied, a humate is a small addition compared with what a topsoil already holds, and it does not replace the residue, manure and cover-crop inputs that build that stock.

For the principles of how humic substances interact with soil, see how potassium humate works in soil and soil structure and water. We do not repeat them here. Our humic acid TDS list the uses: HA-01G as a soil conditioner applied directly to soil and for blending with granular fertilizers; HA-01P as a soil conditioner and as a raw material for granulation and organic or organic-inorganic fertilizers.

For an overview of the topic, see humic substances in agriculture: a reading guide.

FAQ

Does a humic acid product add organic matter to soil?

Yes, in the sense that it is organic material. The amount added is the mass applied times its organic matter content, adjusted for moisture. For humic acid granule HA-01G, the TDS states organic matter ≥ 85.0% on dry basis and moisture ≤ 25.0%.

How much organic matter is one percentage point of SOM?

In the example soil, one percentage point is 26 t of organic matter per hectare in the top 0.20 m (2,600 t × 0.01). This shows the scale involved; it is not a target for humic acid use.

Is humic acid the same as humus?

Not as these words are used here. Humus is an older term for decomposed soil organic matter, and how distinct “humic” substances are in soil is debated (Lehmann and Kleber 2015). Commercial humic acid is extracted or milled from a raw material such as leonardite. See the humic acid product page for our grades.

How should I track soil organic matter?

Sample the same fields at the same depth and season, use the same laboratory and method, and compare results over several years. Record all organic inputs, including residues, manure and any humic products.

References

  • Lehmann J, Kleber M. 2015. The contentious nature of soil organic matter. Nature 528:60–68. doi:10.1038/nature16069
  • Olk DC, Bloom PR, Perdue EM, et al. 2019. Environmental and agricultural relevance of humic fractions extracted by alkali from soils and natural waters. Journal of Environmental Quality 48:217–232. doi:10.2134/jeq2019.02.0041
  • Pribyl DW. 2010. A critical review of the conventional SOC to SOM conversion factor. Geoderma 156:75–83. doi:10.1016/j.geoderma.2010.02.003
  • Weil RR, Brady NC. 2017. The Nature and Properties of Soils, 15th ed. Pearson. ISBN 9780133254556.

Product figures are typical values from our current TDS: SH-HA-01G and SH-HA-01P. The worked example uses assumed values for illustration only.